I disagree with basically that whole interpretation. And the ending was explicitly hopeful. I think you just took it personal that what you thought was gonna happen didn’t.
The fact that she’s “dead” means she’s finally free, and I’m pretty sure Mike’s speech about what if she’s still alive was a strong hint that eventually he’d find her again. Every character got the best possible outcome all considered.
If we take Duffer brothers’ word as gospel, they will never see each other again. Which was the intended message to go along with their “she represents childhood magic, and that has to end for kids to grow up” statement. Nothing hopeful there.
Why are you listening to them when you could just watch the show and make your own opinions? Maybe that’s how the duffer bros intended it, but that’s absolutely not how it came across the screen. I think they got a little high on their own supply because absolutely nothing whatsoever in the show or anything eleven did conveyed the idea that she was supposed to represent childhood magic. I think they had just read IT maybe or were confusing ST for for a random Stephen King story because there was nothing of that at all in the show. It wasn’t that kind of show, any metaphors or analogies are surface level. So you can read their botched interpretation that clearly didn’t come through in the final product or you can just watch the ending with media literacy and see that literally every character remaining gets the happiest possible outcome.
Media literacy tells me two main characters didn’t get their happy endings. It also tells me neither of the endings are logistically possible or make much sense. I think it’s fine we agree to disagree on this.
I disagree with basically that whole interpretation. And the ending was explicitly hopeful. I think you just took it personal that what you thought was gonna happen didn’t.
What’s hopeful about El disappearing from everyone’s life? I’m hardly the only one who sees it this way.
The fact that she’s “dead” means she’s finally free, and I’m pretty sure Mike’s speech about what if she’s still alive was a strong hint that eventually he’d find her again. Every character got the best possible outcome all considered.
If we take Duffer brothers’ word as gospel, they will never see each other again. Which was the intended message to go along with their “she represents childhood magic, and that has to end for kids to grow up” statement. Nothing hopeful there.
Why are you listening to them when you could just watch the show and make your own opinions? Maybe that’s how the duffer bros intended it, but that’s absolutely not how it came across the screen. I think they got a little high on their own supply because absolutely nothing whatsoever in the show or anything eleven did conveyed the idea that she was supposed to represent childhood magic. I think they had just read IT maybe or were confusing ST for for a random Stephen King story because there was nothing of that at all in the show. It wasn’t that kind of show, any metaphors or analogies are surface level. So you can read their botched interpretation that clearly didn’t come through in the final product or you can just watch the ending with media literacy and see that literally every character remaining gets the happiest possible outcome.
Media literacy tells me two main characters didn’t get their happy endings. It also tells me neither of the endings are logistically possible or make much sense. I think it’s fine we agree to disagree on this.