☆ Yσɠƚԋσʂ ☆

  • 2.62K Posts
  • 942 Comments
Joined 7 years ago
cake
Cake day: January 18th, 2020

help-circle























  • The only studies I’m aware of used tiny samples and produced muddled conclusions. If you have some conclusive empirical research then do feel free to share it though. Meanwhile, using LLMs doesn’t mean doing less, it just means focusing on different things. The skill deficit here is the same kind as the skill deficit people have using punch cards or writing assembly by hand today. As things become automated, different things become relevant and that’s what people shift their attention to.



  • Assuming that Linux kernel team continues to use the same review process they always had, there’s zero reason to think that there would be an increased rates of bugs due to LLM generated code. This seems to be something people without programming experience don’t understand. Code quality isn’t premised on trust, it’s a product of the development process. Projects ensure quality by having specifications, tests, doing code reviews, and so on. As long as the practices the kernel team has established continue to be applied, they will catch the bugs made by LLMs or humans exactly the same way.




  • In the commercial context, profit is obviously the selections pressure. However, even here you have to make a product that people are willing to put up with.

    We’ve already gone through something similar back in the early 2000s with the whole outsourcing craze. Companies thought that they could massively cut costs by just outsourcing all the development to places like India. And then came the painful realization that having contractors who don’t give a shit about your product pump out slop doesn’t actually work all that well in practice. The exact same thing applies to LLMs.

    And of course, software development world extends far beyond commercial companies. People working on projects outside commercial constraints can use them as they see fit, and they don’t have to compromise quality to meet profit margins.