But no-- I feel like the benign, wishful sentiment depicted in the last panel was totally human and totally understandable, and sometimes there won’t necessarily be anything more than that. Indeed, that person may go on to self-check, realise what the issue is, and put more focus on understanding others’ specific issues. And that’s a good thing, mais non?
At the same time, I’ve found it incredibly common for some to have a hard time moving through that process, in fact getting stuck there semi-permanently (“here’s my advice for everyone else…” xN). Most often these seem to be orthodox, evangelical sorts. And of course, some can take it much further, going in more toxic directions.
Since I feel like all these things are rather directly connected, the simple comment I made in the beginning was meant to indicate that, not try to put down the cartoon in any way, nor its messages.
Didn’t really think I needed to fully explain that to anyone, but here we are.
Bringing up every connected possibility is not always warranted or needed. We don’t need to soil every attempt at optimism by bringing up every toxic alternative just because. Optimism is hard enough to hold onto already. We should be mindful of needlessly weakening that.
If your optimism is lost by considering other aspects of the situation then i would argue you aren’t optimistic, you’re distracted or deluded.
An optimist would see the other aspects and remain positive, because that’s optimism – just how the opposite would go for a pessimist.
Someone purposefully ignoring or avoiding other aspects ofnthe situation is seeking distraction or delusion, imo, and wouldn’t be considered optimistic.
for the record I don’t think the comic is implying that it comes from a place of love.
Good point. Me, I saw that possibility (as more-or-less stated above), but personally decided to take the balanced, positive road. Evidently that was something of an outrage to some folks, as seen above.
I wonder what @Ech@lemmy.ca will have to say about you examining the ‘dark path.’
Unfortunately, also all-too-possible to slip in to self-righteousness, evangelism, etc.
Eh, the situation in the comic is pretty clearly well meaning.
Wasn’t debating that in the slightest.
Just nitpicking optimistic comments for fun, then? As hobbies go, it’s not the best.
Okay, whatever you say, boss.
But no-- I feel like the benign, wishful sentiment depicted in the last panel was totally human and totally understandable, and sometimes there won’t necessarily be anything more than that. Indeed, that person may go on to self-check, realise what the issue is, and put more focus on understanding others’ specific issues. And that’s a good thing, mais non?
At the same time, I’ve found it incredibly common for some to have a hard time moving through that process, in fact getting stuck there semi-permanently (“here’s my advice for everyone else…” xN). Most often these seem to be orthodox, evangelical sorts. And of course, some can take it much further, going in more toxic directions.
Since I feel like all these things are rather directly connected, the simple comment I made in the beginning was meant to indicate that, not try to put down the cartoon in any way, nor its messages.
Didn’t really think I needed to fully explain that to anyone, but here we are.
Bringing up every connected possibility is not always warranted or needed. We don’t need to soil every attempt at optimism by bringing up every toxic alternative just because. Optimism is hard enough to hold onto already. We should be mindful of needlessly weakening that.
If your optimism is lost by considering other aspects of the situation then i would argue you aren’t optimistic, you’re distracted or deluded.
An optimist would see the other aspects and remain positive, because that’s optimism – just how the opposite would go for a pessimist.
Someone purposefully ignoring or avoiding other aspects ofnthe situation is seeking distraction or delusion, imo, and wouldn’t be considered optimistic.
“We should be mindful of how disruptive our comments are.”
“You’re not really an optimist. You’re just deluded.”
What a reasonable and well meant response.
My comment was not about you specifically. I thought i wrapped it up with general terms clearly enough to show that but maybe not.
Holy overreaction Batman. They were adding shades to your comment, not nitpicking. You know, like discussion? On the internet?
Maybe you should take a wee break.
defensive much? it’s like you feel personally attacked because you do what mr triangle does and are now trying to justify it.
for the record I don’t think the comic is implying that it comes from a place of love.
Good point. Me, I saw that possibility (as more-or-less stated above), but personally decided to take the balanced, positive road. Evidently that was something of an outrage to some folks, as seen above.
I wonder what @Ech@lemmy.ca will have to say about you examining the ‘dark path.’
Dark path, hah!