I read enough about politics that I should know something about this, but I’m drawing a blank.
Nobody cares what happens to the executives, but there are 700,000 to 900,000 people who would be out of a job. Overnight? And no, they can’t all go to work for the government. The transition period would be longer than most could afford and the government won’t need to replicate redundant roles from X number of companies. Am I wrong? Could Medicare absorb all these people?
Medical coding seems like it would survive mostly intact, but the rest? A few people could hang on at private companies if they evolve to be useful, additional insurance. Doesn’t the UK have private insurers like that?
Has this ever been addressed? Am I just dumb and completely missed any talk on the subject? Got to thinking about it because Medicare for All finally has a shot.
They can go fuck themselves, genuinely.
The work they are doing is not useful. They will have to learn how to do a useful thing. This is good because the world does not need people who operate a useless bureaucracy, but the world does need a lot of help in other ways.
They get decent health care.
I would imagine a percentage go work for the new unified provider.
M4A would probably set prices on the treatment options they offer and require the individuals to cover costs above that amount so there’s a good chance that many people would still need private insurance for situations where the hospital they want to use is not covering the full cost of the procedure that they need based off of M4A.
So for like the average person, it generally means cost savings, whereas for people that are suffering from severe long-term issues like cancer or something may end up either being stuck in an eternal waiting queue or still having to purchase private insurance so that they can get their treatment faster.
I grew up in coal/steel country and I knew more than a few older guys who were paid for job retraining when the steel mills closed. I’m not saying it’s the best idea but I think you couple that with paying to retrain people to work in the new system because it will still need people to administer the system.
Maybe, I’m no expert but it is something important to think about.
My dad took advantage if that when his tool and die shop closed down. He got a degree in social work and worked with mentally handicapped adults and loved it until he retired.
They will have to get jobs helping people instead of ripping off sick people
They find a different job subject to supply & demand of the labor market like everyone else.
Most of their skills translate to other jobs.
The resources freed up can go toward work more valuable to society.
Such resource reallocation is the creative destruction economists write about.They’ll be fine. M4A isn’t a proposal to nationalize health insurance and won’t remove profit incentives from the private sector. Currently, Medicare/Medicaid for some has for-profit companies as intermediaries between the government payer and the patients and physicians. They handle all the insurance part of the business, approving and denying claims, etc, and invoice the government for the premiums. Expanding, even universalizing, Medicare and Medicaid only increases their captive market of eligible beneficiaries and would likely be highly profitable.
Will they need to close a datacenter that currently auto-rejects claims? Finally, someone asking the real questions.
Some or all of these would likely happen.
- minimal layoffs as most insurance companies transition to contractors with Medicare to process claims.
- private health insurance is still somewhat common for a significant number of people as Medicare has significant gaps.
- Medicare advantage style plans become widely available to everyone.
- insurance company doctors have to start actually practicing medicine.
- government run rural hospitals would be a new source of employment.
- Medicare would need significantly more staff to handle more than doubling the number of insured.
- insurance companies have significant layoffs as they downsize to running the hospitals and pharmacies that they own, maybe something like a PBM still exists as well.
I don’t think that’s going to happen.
Medicare for all is a public option; not a replacement nor transitioning from one to another.
You can have public & private. Most countries have this option, most have public and don’t get private.
Getting private on top (friends experience in Montreal) of public in two examples:
Medical: you get access to small private clients, acts like a fast pass at Disneyland. Public hospital scheduled out 2+ months (like everyone else around the world; yes, same as private I. The US.), you can see private sooner because most people don’t use it.
Dental: you don’t waste your coverage on health related stuff, public covers it. You get cosmetic related stuff with private, like teeth whiting.
So since us Americans like (not all, obvi) fucking up our image, your private insurance is going to be used her because Medicare for all is just for your health.
Which is nice in the longer run, we should see at least 15% decease traffic in hospital/clinic because now you’re not waiting on someone getting a face lift or bugged out lips.
Edit: additional note: Yes, with the majority of people that will take the public option and private starts letting go employees; the government will already be offering training and hiring. Will we see lay offs before hand? You betcha because the private companies will try to save money as much as possible.
Kaiser Permanente Is a little different since they run and control their whole pipeline. They’re the Apple in medical.
You’re not wrong - eliminating insurance companies will also eliminate a lot of jobs. But it will also create jobs, and a subsequent shift of workers from corporate insurance to these new government roles. And government roles come with added benefits, like a pension and PSLF (student loan forgiveness). For those who don’t end up working for the government, there are many other white-collar roles they can fill. Insurance jobs typically don’t involve much in the way of specialized skills - an office job is an office job is an office job. There will almost certainly be a rough transition period when M4A is implemented, but I’m confident things will shake out.
It’s so weird to me how much America has fucked the reputation of Insurance in the eyes of its own citizens
Insurance is actually a fair and affordable expense in most other developed nations, and actually a ready useful economic tool for individuals and wider society both
Corporations in America are just insanely greedy is all
I’m one of the few who have legal insurance. At $26 a month, it’s saved me more over my divorce and custody cases than I will ever pay in. I can call in, leave a message with customer service, have a layer on the phone, for no additional cost, within an hour. BUT, there’s only one company I know of doing it.
So yeah, insurance can be cheap and work for the people, not against us. But the ridiculous redundancy in our medical insurance systems is, most literally, killing us.
Private insurance isn’t going anywhere. Either some combo or pricy option.





